The Official Game of Thrones Thread

So Game of Thrones had its season premiere last night and I wondered, does anyone else watch this show? If so, what do you think of it? And even if you don’t have HBO, I’m sure there are just as many here who have read the A Song of Ice and Fire novels upon which they’re based.

For me, GoT was pretty much the sole reason for getting HBO. Ocelli and I watched the whole first season in a marathon session, as we found it very addicting!

So I figured there’s got to be other people on here who are familiar with this series, and figured it was time to open up a thread for it.

I really need to see this show.

Coldwin and I are huge fans of the A Song of Ice and Fire series. We got hooked on Game of Thrones when the HBO show first came out and immediately started reading the novels after that. He’s finished the entire series, and I’m almost there, close to done with A Dance With Dragons, after putting it aside for some other projects for a few months. I picked it back up again when the second season of Game of Thrones came back.

Overall, I enjoy the storyline and like most of the characters. My absolute favorite, though, is Tyrion.

So far, the HBO adaptation is pretty good and I know plenty of people that haven’t read the books that enjoy it without them, so it’s not a “you must read the book or you won’t like it” kind of thing. The books might make it easier to follow, as there are a lot of characters in the series who you see in the show that are fleshed out better in the book, which gives certain scenes more emotional impact. But they’re still good regardless.

Love the show, love the books. Dance with Dragons was a relief, he was losing me in a feast for crows.

I have Long Claw in Stainless and Damascus Steel, Ice in Stainless and Cheez has Needle in 1080 High Carbon.

I want Fury but that’s gonna have to wait a bit I’m afraid.

We love GoT as well. We hadn’t read the books first, we got them after the first season ended. What we had learned before reading them is that you cannot grow too fond of anyone there.

And Tyrion Lannister rocks the casbah.

I’m trying to get through the books now. I have the first four in trade paperback and am just waiting for Dance With Dragons to be released in that format as well. I’m also thinking of getting copies for my friend Keri and sending them to her so she’ll have something to read on the inside, as I think she’d like them (although it would be easier if she would actually send me a letter and let me know).

I’m on the first one. But since Season 1 covered much of it, hardly anything that happens is going to be a surprise. It will be interesting, though, to see what some of the differences are. Naturally, some scenes had to be either altered or left out for the sake of time and/or budget. But so far, it hews to the book very nicely.

One of the things that struck me the most was the ages of some of the characters. Jon Snow is said to be 14, and Daenerys is 13. But both the actors who play them, Kit Harington and Emilia Clarke, are both in their 20’s and seem to be depicted as such. Now I know some of that is just because some of the things that happen to the characters, particularly Dany, wouldn’t be acceptable to some of today’s audiences (i.e. I don’t think America is ready to see a an older man forcing himself on 13-year-old girl, even if it is something that’s customary in the books’ world and has been done before in actual past history).

It’s also a bit of a problem keeping track of so many of the different characters. There was already an expansive cast in Season 1, but now we have the other Baratheons and Greyjoys, not to mention Melisandre and Davos. I get the feeling I’m going to need a scorecard to keep track of who everyone is as this goes on.

Right now, though, my favorite characters are Jon Snow, Daenerys, Tyrion Lannister and Arya Stark. And that’s in large part due to the actors who play them, as they’re all very good and likeable. I like watching Jon Snow’s journey as he joins the Night’s Watch. I have a feeling he’s going to grow into a great leader, and I’m also enjoying his friendship with Samwell, who’s an interesting character in his own right. Both Kit Harington and John Bradley have a great chemistry that comes across well on screen.

I’m also a big fan of Emilia Clarke as Dany. And not just because she’s great in the role. Have you seen her naked? Rowr! But seriously, I’m also enjoying her journey too as she goes from this meek young woman under the thumb of her brother into a great leader herself. Will she be a hero or a villain, though? And don’t spoil it for me, please!

Maisie Williams as Arya is also a scene-stealer. In some ways, she reminds me of my niece. And I can easily see her being just as spunky and headstrong when she gets to be that age.

And Peter Dinklage as Tyrion… What can I say? The man may be short in stature, but he’s a giant as far as I’m concerned (and a really cool guy to hang with from what I understand). If you can’t get enough of him, check him out in an upcoming movie called The Knights of Badassdom that’ll be coming out this Summer.

My only concern about this series, really, is that George R.R. Martin will be able to stay alive long enough to see it through to completion. He’s one of those authors that, as the story goes on, keeps adding more to it. I’m hoping that the projected next two books in the series will be the last ones as he says. He’s already well into The Winds of Winter, which would leave only A Dream of Spring left. But I wouldn’t be surprised if he had to add more.

I’m thinking that this thread could also double as a sort of talkback for new episodes. So feel free to post away after watching tonight’s.

I don’t remember the show version changing too much compared to the book for the first season. There are things left out, but on the show they’d have been filler, even though it didn’t feel that way in the book. For instance, the journey in and out of the Vale with Tyrion was longer in the book, and there were more scenes with Viserys before his death in the book… mostly of him treating Daenerys horribly. I doubt the viewer who hadn’t read the books would mourn him on the show, but in the books, he has his end coming even more. And I love how they mocked him for being the “sorefoot king” in the book before that.

Another difference that I’m not sure why they wrote it that way was how in the book, Catelyn was the one encouraging Ned to go to King’s Landing, while in the series she was begging him not to go.

On the age differences, in the upcoming season knowing Sansa’s book age makes how Joffrey treats her even more vile, and it’s easier to see why she’s so naive. Although Arya is even younger than her and she sees how things are, Arya’s far from a typical little noble-lady. Arya is a fun character. I don’t know how many people on this board are familiar with Disney Afternoon shows like Darkwing Duck, but Arya strongly reminds me of a human fantasy-medieval version of Gosalyn Mallard, and it endears me to her even more. Speaking of endearing, I also really like the friendship between Jon and Sam.

In regards to the number of characters, get ready for lots more in this season and the upcoming ones. One great one, Brienne of Tarth, is going to be introduced this season. I ship her and Jaime Lannister (for reasons that’ll become clearer as the series and books go on) pretty hard. George RR Martin put a pretty big cast in this world. The Tyrells of Highgarden and Martells of Dorne play pretty significant roles later in the series. The Greyjoys as well.

Imo they did a very good adaption, they did not really “remove” any big important things. The only thing i miss from the first book is the letter or what ever someone got or sent, lemme check the wikia.. BRB

Yes, this letter Neds brother Benjen sent updating him on matters at hand, and he is not at the watch couching is Brothers son, showing him around and what not.

I’ve read Martin’s Song Of Ice and Fire series and the fantasy novels are really epic.For me he is the modern Tolkien in the fantasy genre. Now i am waiting fo0r his 6th installment, the Winds Of Winter! For those who are now watching HBO’s mass hit i strongly advise to read the 5 novels as well.There is much insight and extensive knowledge of the realm.

The series is very faithful to the original book, encompassing all the main events which took place.Some things are quite reasonable to leave out since it can’t be covered to a 50-minutes episode.Season 2 begun very promising and the good things are now going to be shown!!
HBO’s production is equal to a Hollywood blockbuster movie.No wonder it has received raving reviews so far. Along with Darabont’s ‘Walking Dead’, the best tv-series i’ve seen for a long while!
Peter Dinklage, tyrion Lannister won the golden globe for supporting actor, he has such a phenomenal performance adding depth and wisdom to the whole series.His acting is amazing.
Recently, i purchased the DVD Season 1 from Amazon.

I am a fan of jon snow,he will have a prominent role

So, what did you all think of the most recent episode? I’d been looking forward to seeing how they’d do that scene with Melisandre at the end. I’m also kind of dreading the next episode, but I won’t say why because of spoilers for those who haven’t read the books.

The scene with Joffrey and the prostitutes was a total HBO-ism, not in the books, but I suppose it was a quick and rating-inducing way to get across what a complete little monster he is. Also, while it wasn’t in this episode, since it’s kind of related to this, I noticed that the show had Joffrey order all of Robert’s *******s killed, where in the books, that was Cersei’s work. Again, I presume they’re using that to show how Joffrey is without using up too much screen time, being that they have to condense a huge book into one season. Props to the actor, though. He does a really convincing job with making us feel that he’s a psychopath.

On a lighter note, the “smoked ham” line of Renly’s was delightful. :smiley:

Edit: Darn that censor! The starred out word is another way of saying illegitimate children, if it wasn’t clear from the context.

Good ep. Though Ocelli and I both thought that scene at the end was freaky! And Ocelli says she’s seen her share of freaky things on that show (she’s apparently forgotten the stuff we’ve seen watching Fringe!) For me, that had to be one of the freakiest birth scenes I’ve seen since Species II!

May be par for the course for HBO (they also seem to get carried away with the sex on True Blood, but I ain’t complainin’!;)) But it seems to be in keeping with the spirit of the books. If you haven’t read any of GRRM’s other works, you should see what the characters in his Wild Cards series get up to! He’s quite a deviant little man! :evil:

Yeah, Joffrey’s a psycho. And I’m hoping he gets his before long. Though with that short platinum blond hair, he’s looking a little too much like Draco Malfoy to my liking. And I wish they had made it long like it was described in the books.

Incidentally, am I the only one who, when he handed the scepter to the one prostitute, thought, “Oh god, which end is he going to have her use? Hope it’s not the one with the antlers!”:o

I think I missed that. Have to go back and re-watch.

Best way around that I’ve found is to replace one of the "a"s with the @ symbol.

“For Melisandre’s ladies parts are dark and full of terrors.” Best review of that scene I’ve heard.

2nd place: Awe, your baby dementor is all grown up.

I agree, it was in character for the universe. I just enjoy comparing the book and TV series and seeing what’s done differently, what’s left out, what’s added, and all that jazz.

I wonder if the resemblance to Draco was intentional on their part. They’ve taken some liberties with the character appearances and costumes. Mostly minor stuff. I haven’t seen anyone with crazy colored hair or beards yet. Renly’s kingsguard is also supposed to have rainbow cloaks, which I noticed they didn’t do, either, and I was somewhat disappointed in that.

It’s in the exchange between him and Stannis. There are already a ton of gifs of that moment on Tumblr. I guess I wasn’t the only one who laughed.

Melisandre: “You should kneel before your brother. He’s the Lord’s chosen. Born amidst salt and smoke.”
Renly: “Born amidst salt and smoke? Is he a ham?”

LOL! That needs to be on a T-shirt!:smiley:

I’ve known guys who, if they know a woman’s sexual history, would never go to bed with her; saying, “It’s probably like the Black Hole of Calcutta down there!”

But with Melisandre, it’s literal! I think Stannis would have probably thought twice about sticking his willy in there if he knew he was going to be the baby-daddy of a Shadow Demon, or whatever that is.

I thought the birth scene was the freakiest thing in the GoT series so far. I haven’t read any of the books yet so I’m sure there will be more.

Unfortunately still haven’t been able to watch the 4th episode Garden of Bones .
But i hear it is very good with many revelations.

It was revealing my friend.

Well, the last episode, “The Old Gods and The New,” was pretty exciting. Theon took Winterfell, Arya came within inches of being discovered by Tywin, Joffrey literally got the s**t thrown back in his face…with some of his entourage getting torn to pieces, Sansa nearly getting raped, Jon meeting up with Ygrette, and Daenerys’ dragons getting stolen.

But the scene that stuck out in my mind was Osha’s disrobing. Yes! I got to see Nymphadora Tonks naked!:smiley:

Hey, I’m a man of simple pleasures, and I take them where I can find them. :wink: