I’ve watched these three specials on separate days this week. As the earliest of these dates from 1977, a full decade after the main series ended, and also after the death of Alan Reed, the original voice of Fred, it’s fair to say that, whether you like them or not, these are not representative of the show.
A Flintstone Christmas
This was the only one I saw as a kid. The other two were made around the time I was losing interest in cartoons (however temporarily!), so I never noticed them. Fred having to step in for Santa, yes. Fun. It’s apparently the only one to feature Pebbles and Bam-Bam at that exact age. Also this was the first Flintstones done after Reed’s death, so Henry Corden was still finding his feet as Fred. Of course, if he’s able to use “Christmas Magic” to wish presents for the local kids into existence at the end, how come that didn’t work in the middle when they lost the sack of presents and had to go to the North Pole to get replacements?
A Flintstone Family Christmas
This one, with the thieving kid who learns a lesson about family and loyalty - meh, bit of a cliche, and perhaps typical of the times. This was 1993, and a lot of stories then had these cliched messages. Of note, this was now after Mel Blanc had died, so Barney’s voice here and in the other special was provided by none other than Frank Welker, who got it spot on. At this point Jean Van der Pyl (Wilma) was now the only original cast member left (Betty had changed voices back in the original show’s run already).
A Flintstones Christmas Carol
Sort of contradicting the previous one, in which Fred keeps on about how much he loves christmas, here he’s taken the part of Scrooge a little too much to heart. It’s a little contrived, but he manages to learn the lessons that Scrooge did, thanks to a scare with forgetting to collect the presents and Wilma having to step in to play so many parts. I prefer this to the previous one.
We’re going to have three weeks of regular Flintstones episodes as the show had such a long run, six whole seasons, we’re going to pick two episodes from each season for 14B-D, and then finish off with the feature “The Man Called Flintstone” for 14E - we haven’t spent five weeks on one show since Transformers, the first show we covered!