I’ve said this many times before in the past, but the TV show I always associated - or more accurately, compared - the TCats 2011 reboot with was Battlestar Galactica. If I never clearly explained why, here goes…
The original BSG was a product of the 1970’s. It was regarded as little more than a way for a TV network to ride the Star Wars bandwagon that was sweeping the country at that time. Steeped in tropes of Ancient Astronauts with a slight hint of Mormonism on the side (creator Glen Larson was a member of the LDS church), it was pretty lightweight, weekly TV space opera that was fun to watch, but ultimately didn’t have much else to say.
The original TCats was a product of the 1980’s. A way for another toy company to cash in on the He-Man bandwagon by making their own 30-minute-long toy commerical. It paid lip-service to Star Wars as well as J.R.R. Tolkien and King Arthur, but ultimately had no underlying, bigger message. Instead it was content to deliver ham-handed morals much like other kids TV shows at the time did.
Fast forward 30 years. When BSG was being re-imagined, Ron Moore saw the potential that the original had and decided to take advantage of it. And he brought all those underlying themes and subtexts to the forefront. As the basic premise dealt with the near-destruction of humanity, the show became significantly darker. He also used the show to address the issues of the day like terrorism, 9/11, the invasion and occupation of Iraq, Abu Ghraib and others (probably too much for its own good). Fans were divided, but those who did like the new version loved it passionately. And whther you loved it or hated it, it can;t be argues that BSG ended up bieng one of the most memorable Science Fiction shows in the past 10 years.
Like Ron Moore, Dan Norton saw the potential for Thundercats to be the truly epic series that it always could have been with a sweeping scope and an ongoing story arc. He embraced that idea and ran with it. Compred to the original, which was light and campy, the new version was significantly darker and serious. As with BSG, fans were divided, but those that liked it loved it very passionately. It was certainly one of the more ambitious animated shows on TV at the time, which is why it was so fondly remembered.
So that’s how I always regarded the show. Don’t know if it holds up under scrutiny, but that’s always been my take on it.