I only bought the Shout! Factory DVDs for G.I. Joe as I’m not that big of a fan but wanted to add to my 80’s DVD collection (I must admit after watching some, wished I had gotten more into these as a kid). But I have both the Shout! Factory and the Rhino Transformers DVD sets and the Shout set is far and away superior. The Matrix of Leadership edition is the best public edition of Transformers, IMO and I’ve read nothing but great reviews about it (if for no other reason than for some of the great DVD extras).
I’ve also read on some forums that people, while happy to have Thundercats on DVD, weren’t exactly blown away by Warner Bros. crack at it. There appeared to be no attempt at restoration of the source material, and the bonus material that I have watched (some fan commentation) is bare bones in comparison to either of those DVD set releases.
That’s all the reason for a proper set to be released. Shortly after posting this I sadly read on the Shout! Factory website that currently the deal is only for Max Headroom and no animations are being considered at this time. I think a 25th anniversary DVD set with as much video and audio restoration as possible along with similar bonus features offered in those two sets (the character booklet, toy commercials, etc) would be a proper DVD set for the series.
Not only that but if the fans can get behind this concept, it could lead to other Rankin/Bass productions that either have only had half a release or none at all (SilverHawks, The Comic Strip come to mind) to possibly finally be completed or see the light of day. Shout! Factory, unlike Warner Bros. has an excellent track record (not perfect by their bare bones attempt at C.O.P.S., but that was 4 years ago) of doing justice to similar shows of this era. I can’t think of a better year to update the Thundercats DVD set than this one and just like with Transformers, you put “25th Anniversary” on the label and fans will buy it.
Merged Post:
For anyone who really isn’t familiar with the numbers, let me break it down for you (from memory so to speak)
There were 5 DVDs of the Rhino Transformers set, each initially retailing for around $50 plus tax. If you add those up that is $250 total worth of sales. That was probably somewhat of a turnoff for Transformers fans. If you look at the 25th Anniversary single season sets currently being released, they are retailing for about $30 a piece. I believe, initially, the Matrix of Leadership box set when it first shipped July of last year was about $145 plus shipping from Shout! (before it hit retail). That’s about $100 difference in price. I don’t have any sales numbers for those sets (if someone can get them or a sale report from Shout! to post here that would be fantastic) so I can’t speak to that, however the price point difference I’m sure brought on some fans that missed the Rhino releases. Also, from some of the sights I’ve read that have reviewed the DVD set have said it is the definitive Transformers series DVD set to have for the original G1 show. If need be to apease Grizzlor, I’ll go digging around to try to find some testimonials to try to see if there’s evidence of a significant amount of people that owned the Rhino set like myself that also went out and got the Matrix of Leadership edition.
In any other year, I would agree with Grizzlor that it probably wouldn’t be worthwhile sales wise. But tagging the set with “25th Anniversary edition”, updating the bonus content with fresh stuff, attempting to digitally restore/remaster the series, and chopping it down to about $115-$125 for a complete box set I think would get some fans that didn’t shell out the $200+ for the 4 volumes of Warner Bros “lackluster” offering, to jump on and snag that set up.
:liono
If anyone out there owns either of the sets Shout! put out last year, I would think you’d have to want to see this happen.
Merged Post:
Just found this over at the Shout! Factory forum
http://www.shoutfactory.com/community/2121/thread.aspx
Brian I believe is either the head of Shout! or very high up on the chain. Somewhere about 10 or so posts down he says they hope to do a great release on Max Headroom so WB will allow them to release more shows.
Again, there’s 0 reference to Thundercats in this thread, but if WB has any marketing brains at all, they will try to capitalize on the silver anniversary of the show with a box set.
Also hopefully Silverhawks and the comic strip would find there way in, but for now here’s hoping for a truely great Thundercats DVD set!! I don’t expect there to be any more news on future liscenses until after August as that appears to be when the set will hit retail. I’ll continue to monitor it and post any updates, but that shouldn’t stop any fans who either
A) Are ardent fans of Thundercats who weren’t blown away by WB’s go at the Cats DVD release
OR
B) Have previous Shout! Factory releases that can attest to how well this company does box sets for similar shows
From going to forums like Shout’s and any Warner Bros ones and voicing for Thundercats to have a Shout! set released!